DOWNTOWN
NEWS
Nov.
15, 2004
THEATER
REVIEW
Is East West Players and Cornerstone Collaboration
Heretical or Just Plain Heavy-Handed?
by Rob Kendt
CONTRIBUTING
WRITER
"This
pious piece of propaganda" is not how most Indians think of the Ramayana,
one of two national epic tales (the other is the Mahabharata) that mythologize
an ancient history of conquest and conflict into vast supernatural struggles.
But that's how it's pegged by Ravana (Sean T. Krishnan), the unlikely hero of As
Vishnu Dreams, Shishir Kurup's new adaptation of the Ramayana, at East West
Players' David Henry Hwang through Dec. 5.
We
can see Ravana's point: An army of North Indians from Ayodha, led by the
purportedly divine Rama (Sunkrish Bala), is gathering to invade Ravana's
supposedly demonic domain, the island of Lanka, for the mere crime of abducting
Rama's chaste bride Sita (Meena Serendib). Ravana objects not only to this
Northern aggression but to its self-aggrandizing moral dimension, which he sees
as a pretty mask for ugly motives. What's coming to Lanka, he warns, is an
"occupying force that threatens our cultural sovereignty," an
"imperial power" that must be resisted.
When
the Ayodhans do invade, they "shock" the island's inhabitants
"into a state of awe." Somehow the weapons of Rama and his brother
Lakshman (Rene Millan) even manage to pollute Lankan streams. (Are their arrows
dipped in depleted uranium?) But this is a "liberation," Rama
proclaims hollowly at a press conference. We would hardly blink if, in Kurup's
adaptation, assorted Lankan "insurgents" were then rounded up and
thrown into a prison to be tortured and interrogated without due process.
Grafting
Iraq onto this ancient Indian tale is in itself not very interesting--indeed,
Kurup hammers the analogies a little too insistently, as if we're in danger of
missing them. But at its best, Kurup's adaptation--a collaboration between East
West Players and Cornerstone Theater Company as part of its
"faith-based" cycle of plays--successfully complicates this familiar
fairy tale with tragic elements reminiscent of the Greeks or Shakespeare.
Deaths have implications; retribution is never a clean exchange; fate is an
excuse more than an inevitability.
And
the show's humanization of a storied demon king is not a whitewash; as with
John Gardner's Grendel, which retold Beowulf from the monster's point of view, As
Vishnu Dreams doesn't absolve Ravana so much as it introduces a bracing
ambiguity into the theology of evil.
That's
the good news. Kurup's revision, unfortunately, turns Rama into a figure of
considerably less dimension--an arrogant straw man who barely even understands
the divine justification for his violence. If Kurup's Ravana at times evokes
Macbeth or King Lear's vengeful, accursed Edmund, this bland Rama is an
uninspiring puppet.
Far
more enchanting are the brilliant shadow puppets designed by Lynn Jeffries, who
enact key portions of the tale with an infectiously irreverent tone reminiscent
of Terry Gilliam's Monty Python segments. And director Juliette Carrillo's
production is itself a heroic effort, alternating stark storybook staging and
stylized movement (choreography by Naila Azad) for as much variety as possible.
Christopher Acebo's set, framed by a huge painting of a dreaming Vishnu, is a
gorgeous geometric diorama in primary colors, which seems to shift shape
artfully under Geoff Korf and Jessica Trundy's lighting. I was less persuaded
by Ivy Chou's costuming, an unconvincing mix of traditional, contemporary, and
generic tribal.
Though
a beguilingly impassive narrator (Natch Narasimhan) assures us that the tale
will be told "in a time frame that a Western audience can endure,"
the show's tiring second act is a drawn-out roundelay of flash-forward,
exposition and speechifying confrontation. As has been the case with some of
his previous scripts for Cornerstone Theater Company, Kurup doesn't know when
to stop; he buries his prodigious wit and often startling insights in a welter
of wordplay and a surfeit of signifiers.
This
overkill probably doesn't fully explain why the second act audience on opening
night was about a third smaller than the first act's. Perhaps Indian Americans
aren't keen to embrace such a pointed subversion of a beloved myth--a founding
narrative of Hinduism, in fact. Though it's ostensibly part of Cornerstone's
ongoing faith-based cycle of plays, As Vishnu Dreams may simply be too
hectoring and heterodox for the faithful.